A reader from Beijing China asks (and I’m tickled to be addressed as “Dear teacher” instead of “Hey!” or “I need some help over here!”):
He was seen as having left before midnight.
I am confused whether the above works for you also. A friend told me that we couldn’t see him having left because the act of his leaving happened before I saw. May I have your opinions? If my friend is wrong, could you please give a circumstance when the sentence would be said? Thanks.
Here’s how I answered:
When we use the verb “seen” it doesn’t necessarily mean physically seen. It often means that we understand that this happened. I could say “I see President Obama as a new hope for the US” even though I can’t see him and I’ve never seen him in person.
So, in your sentence, it means he was understood to have left before midnight; however, there is an element of doubt. He might have fallen asleep in the corner and no one knew he was still there.
HyperGraphix offers editing and proofreading services for essays and other documents starting at $3.75 per page.For a free one paragraph edit, click here. For Free Grammar Help, click here.
Please visit our website to ask a question about any essay topic. Visit our FaceBook page. Please feel free to comment at www.HGPublishing.com/Comments.html